Ollie vs. Blue Buffalo

SPONSORED

Choosing the right dog food for your pup can be hard. When you care about your dog’s health and quality of life, nourishing your dog with real and honest meals is one of the most important aspects of pet parenting. Avoiding the well-disguised toxins and unregulated ingredients in commercial dry dog food couldn’t be more of a priority in a world of dog food recalls. That’s why we’ve reviewed Ollie, the top personalized meal delivery service and Blue Buffalo, a premium dry dog food to help you make the right decision for your pup.

Ollie

Attracting health-conscious celebrity investors like Serena Williams, Ollie has been coined the miracle dog food of 2019. Personalized for your individual dog’s breed, weight, physical activity, and allergies, Ollie understands that every dog is different. That’s why Ollie dog food is formulated by a team of specialized veterinarians to bring your dog perfectly balanced nourishment. Slow-cooked in a kettle cooker to maximize nutritional value, Ollie’s nutrition-packed ingredients work together to improve digestion, skin health, and coat. Handmade in small batches at USDA regulated facility, Ollie dog food delivers perfectly pre-portioned meals straight to your doorstep.

Blue Buffalo

Based in the United States, Blue Buffalo offers wet and dry dog food for all dogs of all life stages. With over 230 products, Blue Buffalo dog food is made with real meats and natural ingredients. From puppy to senior dog formulas, Blue Buffalo’s dog food always features meat as the first ingredient to help dogs maintain their health and well-being. Blue Buffalo also offers a wide variety of pet food for dogs with food intolerences or allergies. Blue Buffalo can found in pet-specialty stores like Petco as well as online.

The Comparison

 

Ollie

Blue Buffalo

Flavor
9 out of 10 dogs prefer the taste of Ollie compared to other dog foods.
The taste just didn’t match up to Ollie.
Variety
Four recipes: beef, chicken, turkey, or lamb.
Selection of dry and wet dog foods.
Money Back Guarantee
100% money back guarantee.
No money back guarantee.
Ease of Transition
FREE probiotic pack to help dog’s food transition.
Does not include a free probiotic pack.
First Box Offer
50% off your first box.
No Promotional.
Packaging
Recyclable resealable trays with a perfect portion size scooper.
Bags are not pre-portioned, recyclable, nor resealable.
Charitability
Donates 1% of all its revenue to shelters and rescues.
No official charitable donation.
Product Offerings
Snack line provides the same high-quality ingredients as its food.
Offers food and treats for both cats and dogs.
USDA Certification
USDA certified.
Not USDA certified.
Vet Approval
Specialized veterinarians help formulate AAFCO-compliant recipes.
Not veterinarian approved.
Meal Plan Price
Starts at $3/day.
Starts at $52.98/24 lb bag.
Delivery
Free.
No delivery.

The Verdict

The Winner? Ollie. The number of dog food recalls on Blue Buffalo is heartbreaking. It only takes a bit of digging to find some of the horror stories associated with Blue Buffalo dog food. While we do commend Blue Buffalo for attempting to rise above other commercial dog foods, it’s no match for Ollie’s fresh human-grade dog food. Only Ollie dog food is customized for your dog’s weight, physical activity, breed, and medical conditions. From the human-grade quality to the free pack of probiotics to help your dog feel great during the transition – Ollie really did think of it all! I feel so much better since switching to a dog food I can trust, but most importantly I know my pup is feeling better too!

For a limited time through Insider Envy, you can get an exclusive 50% off your first box of Ollie.

At InsiderEnvy we only promote products we love. We participate in a small number of affiliate programs, meaning we may receive compensation when you buy items after clicking a link on InsiderEnvy. We appreciate your support!

by Insider Envy Staff

x
This site uses cookies to help us serve you better. By continuing to explore our site, you accept our use of cookies. ✓ Accept
x
Welcome back! This site uses cookies to help us serve you better and we have updated our Privacy Policy since your last visit. By continuing to explore our site, you accept our use of cookies. ✓ Accept