The Farmer’s Dog vs. Blue Buffalo


Finding the best food for your dog is never the easiest. You want the healthiest food possible for your furry friend. If you’ve researched dog health, you’ve read about all of the unbelievable benefits your dog can receive from healthy, high-quality ingredients. We are on the exact same page as you – your pup deserves the best of the best: vitamin-rich, nutritious food. We’ve gathered all the details about two of the most popular food companies, so that you can choose the best option for your dog.

The Farmer's Dog

The Farmer’s Dog is built upon nutritious recipes, carefully crafted by board-certified, veterinary nutritionists. All of their ingredients are sourced from local farms and well-known food suppliers, completely abiding by USDA standards. Filled with proteins, vitamins, and minerals, The Farmer’s Dog’s ingredients are fresh and never processed! Committed to the environment, The Farmer’s Dog ships their food in BPA-free, non-toxic, recyclable, and biodegradable packaging.

Blue Buffalo

Blue Buffalo brands themselves as a natural pet food company that produces wet food, kibble, and treats. Their food was developed by holistic veterinarians and animal nutritionists, with a focus on immune system health, and what your dog needs at each stage of their life. While their food contains real meat, there has been some debate over whether Blue Buffalo is totally safe for your dog. We compiled the facts to understand what the difference truly is between Blue Buffalo and The Farmer’s Dog.

The Comparison

The Farmer’s Dog Blue Buffalo
Variety Turkey, beef and pork. Turkey, chicken, beef, duck, fish, venison, rabbit
Types of food Fresh Wet; kibble; prescription
Money-Back Guarantee 100% money-back guarantee 100% money-back guarantee
First Box Offer 20-50% off your first box No offer
Personalized Meal Plan Yes No
Packaging Recyclable and biodegradable. Included resealable packaging Not specified recyclable. Non-resealable.
Product Offerings Fresh food Foods and treats
USDA Certification USDA-certified Not USDA-certified
FDA Warnings None 1 of 16 dog food companies on the FDA’s warning list for being linked to canine heart disease
Vet Approval Recipes formulated by board-certified, veterinary nutritionists. Abides by AAFCO standards. Food formulated by holistic veterinarians and animal nutritionists.
Meal Plan Price Starts at $2/day with free shipping $2-3/can
Delivery Free shipping Does not ship from website

The Verdict

The winner in this comparison is easily The Farmer’s Dog. After digging deeper, we found that the fresh food product offered by The Farmer’s Dog provides a better, more natural and unprocessed alternative to that of Blue Buffalo. As mentioned, Blue Buffalo is 1 of 16 dog food companies identified by the FDA as associated with canine dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM), or canine heart disease, for their grain free products. While the FDA is not calling for a complete stop in the use of the listed brands, many vets are suggesting to move away from grain free brands that don’t meet nutritional standards.

By contrast, with USDA-certified, AAFCO-standard-met, fresh, deliverable, personalized dog food starting at only $2/day, we are confident that The Farmer’s Dog is providing the best possible food for your dog. Plus, The Farmer’s Dog’s at home delivery and pre-portioned meals make it unbelievably easy to keep your dog healthy and full. Lastly, their eco-friendly packaging and first box offer really seals the deal. We can’t get enough of a company that wants the best for you, your dog and the environment!

Now through Insider Envy, you can get 50% off your first box of The Farmer’s Dog through this link.

At Insider Envy we only promote products we love. We participate in a small number of affiliate programs, meaning we may receive compensation when you buy items after clicking a link on Insider Envy. We appreciate your support!

by Insider Envy Staff

This site uses cookies to help us serve you better. By continuing to explore our site, you accept our use of cookies. ✓ Accept