Ollie vs. The Farmer’s Dog


We know choosing your dog food can be hard. Especially when you want only the absolute best for your pup. If you’re considering buying Ollie or Farmer’s Dog dog food you probably already know some of the benefits that can come from feeding your dog food that has healthy ingredients, we couldn’t agree more! Your pet deserves real, honest meals- not the well-disguised toxins and unregulated ingredients that is commercial dry dog food. We’ve researched two of the top personalized pet food delivery services to help you make the right decision for your pup.


All Ollie meals are handmade in a human-grade facility using fresh, USDA certified ingredients and procedures. Formulated by a team of specialized veterinarians, Ollie’s ingredients are slow-cooked using a kettle cooker to maximize their nutritional value, while also ensuring prolonged freshness and superior taste! These nutrition-packed ingredients work together to improve digestion, skin health, and coat. To check for quality, Ollie sends samples from each batch of doggie meals to a third party tester, so every meal you get from Ollie is fresh and full of flavor! Ollie meals are packaged in resealable, recyclable plastic trays and sent to you using insulated cardboard boxes.

The Farmer’s Dog Specifics

Created to cure the health issues of one of its cofounder’s dogs, The Farmer’s Dog is dedicated to providing fresh, wholesome food to dogs everywhere. Made in USDA certified kitchens, The Farmer’s Dog meals are carefully designed by veterinary nutritionists and cooked at low temperatures to make sure none of the nutritional value is lost while cooking. Dedicated to the health of you and your dog, The Farmer’s Dog uses only recyclable, biodegradable, and compostable packaging materials, packaging your pup’s meals in soft, compact bags that can be stored in your refrigerator or freezer.

The Comparison

Ollie Farmer’s Dog
Variety Four recipes: beef, chicken, turkey, or lamb. Three recipes: turkey, beef and pork.
Money Back Guarantee 100% money back guarantee. No money back guarantee.
First Box Offer 20 – 50% off your first box. 20 – 50% off your first box.
Packaging Recyclable resealable trays with a perfect portion size scooper. Soft bags with more than one serving in each bag are not pre-portioned nor resealable – you’ll need to fold up the leftover pack and store it in the container.
Charitability Donates 1% of all its revenue to shelters and rescues. No official charitable donation.
Product Offerings Snack line provides the same high-quality ingredients as its food. Doesn’t offer any products outside of dog’s daily meals.
USDA Certification USDA certified. USDA certified.
Vet Approval Specialized veterinarians help formulate AAFCO-compliant recipes. Veterinarian approved.
Meal Plan Price Starts at $2/day. Starts at $2/day.
Delivery Free. Free.

The Verdict

We were super impressed with both companies, but Ollie narrowly came out on top in a side by side comparison to the Farmer’s Dog. From the human-grade quality food made in small batches at a USDA regulated facility to it’s recyclable packaging – Ollie really did think of it all! I feel so much better since switching to a dog food I can trust, but most importantly I know my pup is feeling better too!

Now through Insider Envy, you can get 50% off your first box of Ollie.

New Packaging Update

Ollie just released their new packaging and it’s pretty great. The old packs used to be bulky and take up a lot of space in your fridge, so they switched to much smaller and denser ones. This means you’ll get more food per box and therefore will have less frequent shipments (huge environmental plus). Portion sizes will be a lot easier to follow with the smaller packs and they’ve also updated their instructions. All in all a good move by Ollie.

At InsiderEnvy we only promote products we love. We participate in a small number of affiliate programs, meaning we may receive compensation when you buy items after clicking a link on InsiderEnvy. We appreciate your support!

by Insider Envy Staff

This site uses cookies to help us serve you better. By continuing to explore our site, you accept our use of cookies. ✓ Accept
Welcome back! This site uses cookies to help us serve you better and we have updated our Privacy Policy since your last visit. By continuing to explore our site, you accept our use of cookies. ✓ Accept