ButcherBox vs Good Chop: The Best Meat and Seafood Subscription Service in 2024


By Insider Envy Staff

In today’s fast-paced world, convenience and quality are two cornerstones that people seek when it comes to sourcing their groceries, especially when it comes to meat and seafood. With the rise of subscription-based meat delivery services, home cooks and health-conscious individuals have found the perfect solution to their culinary needs. Across the many options available, ButcherBox is by far the most established and popular choice in the United States. Founded in 2015 by a community-funded Kickstarter, the employee-owned company has served an impressive 1.5 million members since they started due to their reputation for providing the highest quality meat and seafood on the market. Over the years lots of alternatives have sprung up to try and compete with ButcherBox, including the HelloFresh-owned Good Chop, founded in 2021. 

We decided to dive deep into the offerings, services, and overall experiences provided by ButcherBox and Good Chop to come to a verdict of which service is better, so you can decide which service is right for you. 

ButcherBox reigns supreme in quality and sourcing

After looking through all available options with both services, we concluded that ButcherBox wins when it comes to quality. They are the only B-Corp Certified meat and seafood company to source only from partners with third-party animal welfare certifications, meaning you can trust their products are all high quality, and sourced sustainably. We’ll dive into where each service gets their meat and seafood from:​

​Beef: While both services tout their commitment to quality, only ButcherBox provides 100% grass-fed AND grass-finished beef. While Good Chop’s beef is sourced from cows that are grass-fed for a majority of their lives, they are finished on grain.  

​Chicken: Both services offer chicken that has no added antibiotics or hormones, however all of ButcherBox’s chicken offerings are either free-range and organic or pasture-raised heirloom. 

Pork: Both ButcherBox and Good Chop provide pork products that are sourced from heritage-breed pigs, but ButcherBox goes the extra mile to ensure their pork is humanely raised crate-free, meaning they were never confined to crates during raising. ​

Seafood: Both ButcherBox and Good Chop provide wild-caught seafood, and both partner with fisheries that are certified by the Marine Stewardship Council or Responsible Fisheries Management, so we give them even marks here. We will note that Good Chop’s steelhead trout is farm-raised.​

Plan Flexibility: More Options with ButcherBox

While both ButcherBox and Good Chop offer fully customizable box options, ButcherBox also offers curated boxes for those who prefer to sit back and leave the choosing to the ButcherBox experts. With ButcherBox’s curated boxes, all you have to do is select the types of meat you want included in your box, and they’ll handle the rest. ​

In addition, ButcherBox offers flexible delivery options, allowing customers to choose to have a box delivered every 2, 4, 6, or 8 weeks. They also make it easy to skip a delivery in case you’re out of town or you’re still working through your previous box. Good Chop only offers a 4 week delivery option, which may not be ideal for those who prefer more frequent or more spread out deliveries. ​


Lastly, ButcherBox allows users to add additional cuts to their box each month at discounted member prices, and they send emails to their members with exclusive member deals. ​


ButcherBox advertises their price per serving starts at $3.50, while Good Chop advertises that their price per serving starts at $3.74. ​In addition, ButcherBox shipping is free while Good Chop charges an additional $9.99 each month for shipping.


While both ButcherBox and Good Chop offer convenient solutions for premium meat and seafood delivery, ButcherBox emerges as the superior choice for those seeking top-tier meat & seafood, flexible subscription options, and convenience at a reasonable price point. 

At Insider Envy we only promote products we love and want to let you know that while we participate in a number of affiliate programs, (meaning we may receive compensation when you buy items after clicking a link on Insider Envy), we do not base our reviews on whether or not we receive compensation. Additionally, these fees do not affect the prices you pay for products and services listed on Insider Envy. We appreciate your support!


by Insider Envy Staff

This site uses cookies to help us serve you better. By continuing to explore our site, you accept our use of cookies. ✓ Accept
Welcome back! This site uses cookies to help us serve you better and we have updated our Privacy Policy since your last visit. By continuing to explore our site, you accept our use of cookies. ✓ Accept