ButcherBox vs Good Ranchers: The Best Meat and Seafood Subscription Service in 2024


By Insider Envy Staff

In today’s fast-paced world, meat and seafood subscription services have become the ultimate game-changer in culinary convenience. Not only is it like having your own personal butcher and fishmonger on speed dial, but many subscriptions also cater to your ethical and sustainability concerns. Think grass-fed beef, free-range chicken, and sustainably sourced seafood. Plus, with customizable options galore, you can tailor your subscription to fit your dietary needs and taste preferences.


In this article we take a close look at ButcherBox and Good Ranchers, two of the top names in the meat and seafood subscription market, to decide which brand reigns supreme when it comes to quality, price, and options. Let’s break it down, shall we?

Quality: ButcherBox shines where it matters most

When it comes to quality, ButcherBox is bringing the A-game… or should we say B-game, since ButcherBox is one of the only companies in the space that is B Corp certified, which means they partner exclusively with farms and fisheries that adhere to rigorous standards, ensuring that every item in their subscription boxes meets the highest quality criteria. ButcherBox sources 100% grass-fed and finished beef, free-range organic or pasture-raised heirloom chicken, heritage-breed pork, and wild-caught seafood. What’s more, their products are free of added hormones and antibiotics. That’s a tough act to follow for Good Ranchers. 


Good Ranchers also demonstrates a strong commitment to quality, providing heritage-breed pork, chicken free from added hormones and antibiotics, and wild-caught seafood. Their beef however, is grass-fed, grain-finished, which is a step down from ButcherBox’s 100% grass-fed beef.

Available options: customization and flexibility

ButcherBox is the obvious winner when it comes to customization, since only they offer a custom box. With their custom box, users select from over 50 options, allowing them to tailor each delivery to their preferences. There are additional cuts and add-ons available for existing members, further expanding the options. For users less interested in customizing their own box, ButcherBox also offers three curated boxes for users to choose from. 


Good Ranchers on the other hand only offers curated boxes, and users can select between 14 available boxes with varying meat and seafood options. 


Both services offer flexibility in delivery frequency, with options ranging between every 4, 6, and 8 weeks. ButcherBox has a bit more flexibility, offering an every 2 week delivery option, and users can choose the day of the week to have their box delivered. 

Price: the most value for your dollar

Let’s dive into the nitty-gritty of pricing, shall we? After crunching the numbers, it’s clear that ButcherBox takes the crown when it comes to the most bang for your buck. Looking at Good Ranchers’ most popular Ranchers Classic box, which offers 9.9-10.5 lbs of meat for $194, you will be paying in the range of $18.50 – $20 per pound. ButcherBox’s custom box with the same cuts as the Ranchers Classic box is priced at $169 and offers 12.25 lbs of meat, coming out to $13.80 per pound. 


The cherry on top with ButcherBox is that they almost always run promotions, offering an additional free cut in every box and effectively reducing the cost to as low as $11.86 per pound. ButcherBox members also receive additional promotions each month that they can apply to their next box.

ButcherBox emerges as the clear winner

In the showdown between ButcherBox and Good Ranchers, there can only be one winner. And folks, it’s ButcherBox, hands down. With their top-notch quality, wallet-friendly prices, and flexibility for days, they’re serving up a meaty masterpiece that’s hard to beat. Say hello to your new go-to for all things meat and seafood—you won’t regret it!

At Insider Envy we only promote products we love and want to let you know that while we participate in a number of affiliate programs, (meaning we may receive compensation when you buy items after clicking a link on Insider Envy), we do not base our reviews on whether or not we receive compensation. Additionally, these fees do not affect the prices you pay for products and services listed on Insider Envy. We appreciate your support!


by Insider Envy Staff

This site uses cookies to help us serve you better. By continuing to explore our site, you accept our use of cookies. ✓ Accept
Welcome back! This site uses cookies to help us serve you better and we have updated our Privacy Policy since your last visit. By continuing to explore our site, you accept our use of cookies. ✓ Accept