Fresh Pet vs. Ollie


Looking for the perfect dog food for your pup? We know it can be challenging especially when your dog’s health is at stake. If you’re considering Fresh Pet or Ollie dog food, you’re probably already aware of the dangerous and toxic ingredients in commercial dog food. As pet parents, we know how important it is to nourish your dog with nutritionally complete meals made of real whole foods – not chemicals and preservatives. Check out our head to head comparison of two of the top pet food brands to help you make the right decision for your pup.

Fresh Pet

Fresh Pet offers all natural dog food, fresh from the fridge. Using 100% farm-raised meat and veggies, Fresh Pet dog recipes are steam-cooked and free of preservatives. Fresh Pet dog food is then vacuum sealed and shipped to stores. You can find Fresh Pet sold in stores such as Walmart and Target as well as in pet specialty stores.  Refrigerated dog food at its finest, Fresh Pet includes rolls, roasted meals, and shredded meats for puppies, small dogs, and adult dogs.


Handmade in small batches at USDA regulated facility, Ollie’s customized meal delivery service is free of artificial flavors, preservatives, or fillers. Ingredients are sourced from only high-quality farms, so they’re hormone-free, pasture-raised, and human-grade. These nutrition-packed ingredients work together to improve digestion, skin health, and coat. Formulated by a team of specialized veterinarians, Ollie personalized meals to your pup’s breed, weight, activity, and allergies. As a first-time user, Ollie will offer and 100% money-back guarantee in addition to offering 50% off your subscription.

The Comparison


Fresh Pet

9 out of 10 dogs prefer the taste of Ollie compared to other dog foods.
The taste just didn’t match up to Ollie.
Four recipes: beef, chicken, turkey, or lamb.
22 pet food “rolls” and 10 bagged products.
Money Back Guarantee
100% money back guarantee.
No money back guarantee.
Ease of Transition
Offers meal plans ranging from 15 -100% Ollie allowing you to ease in the new food during the first week.
Does not include transitional meal options.
First Box Offer
50% off your first box.
No promotional.
Recyclable resealable trays with a perfect portion size scooper.
Recyclable vacuum-sealed packaging.
Donates 1% of all its revenue to shelters and rescues.
Fresh Start campaign raises awareness for shelter animals.
Product Offerings
Snack line provides the same high-quality ingredients as its food.
Offers food and treats for both cats and dogs.
USDA Certification
USDA certified.
USDA certified.
Vet Approval
Specialized veterinarians help formulate AAFCO-compliant recipes.
Veterinarian approved.
Meal Plan Price
Starts at $3/day.
Products range from$5-$30.
No delivery.

The Verdict

The Winner? Ollie. While both Ollie and Fresh Pet are dedicated to bringing complete and balanced meals for dogs at all life stages, we found Fresh Pet’s “Best by” dates to be suspiciously long for their unpreserved product line. Ollie’s dog food is always fresh. Only Ollie allows you to personalize your dog’s meal to their age, weight, and breed to precisely measure the exact nutrients for them. 9 out of 10 dogs prefer Ollie compared to other dog foods because of it’s consistent quality and taste. Ollie also offers transitional meal plans of smaller portions along with a 100% money back guarantee. Ollie’s dog food is handmade and delivered straight to your door, not the store.
Now through InsiderEnvy, you can get 50% off your first box of Ollie.

At InsiderEnvy we only promote products we love. We participate in a small number of affiliate programs, meaning we may receive compensation when you buy items after clicking a link on InsiderEnvy. We appreciate your support!

by Insider Envy Staff

This site uses cookies to help us serve you better. By continuing to explore our site, you accept our use of cookies. ✓ Accept
Welcome back! This site uses cookies to help us serve you better and we have updated our Privacy Policy since your last visit. By continuing to explore our site, you accept our use of cookies. ✓ Accept